Ok I decided to fast forward this puzzle to get the game moving forward once more. Below is the correct solution to the puzzle just to give you guys an idea of how it worked. The one symbol you got wrong was the last one the Eel.
Also I'll put up a post on the recruitment thread for Astrid's spot in the game and will NPC her till then.
Ok Happy Mother's Day this Sunday to all Moms. No matter what, they are the most precious thing you will ever know