...I just kind of assumed that Brom was using Shark Tooth's "given name" of Wiley. That said, I can see how it might've gotten confusing.
Additionally, I
was going to give Maggie a bit of hell about being the first person to kill someone on this gods-forsaken island until I realized the timestamps gave that dubious honor to Fin... Not even two hours after the Sun Dog put into port. So very glad the dice were on my side with that one.
Edit: I guess Shark Tooth's name is actually spelled Wylie...