First things first...
1. Everyone stop posting for the moment. I'll have something up by the time I go to bed tomorrow to get us moving along, I think I have something in mind.
2. I both OOC and IC mentioned that everyone needed to work on working as a team.
I was very impressed with generally how well that worked, finally, once you all entered into combat. You not only defeated the enemy, but you did so without inflicting injury on each other or spending more time arguing with each other than fighting. Kudos.
However... I think there is something about 'teamwork' that in my world implies that you don't finish a decent bit of work and then spend the next five posts bashing your fellow players on their actions. Your new professor offered up his suggestions for future improvements, which is proper and expected as he is the TEACHER, the rest of you are STUDENTS... congratulate each other... discuss what to do next and unless we want this school to degrade into factions that will do better fighting against each other than a fellow school, DROP THE CRITICSM OF YOUR FELLOW TEAMATES. That goes for each and everyone of you. I don't want to hear why 'so and so wouldn't make a good leader, or who failed to act in a proper way according to you.' If this is 'how my character would respond' go ahead and try it and see how they respond to Professor O'Leary kicking them out of the school. If your character is truely that much of a 'independent rebel' they can simply stalk off and take on future challenges by themselves. Part of gaming is that it is not a solo enterprise. You all choose to do D&D knowing you would have to do it with a group of other people, and in this venue they are usually a group of people you have never met in real life and know little about. Part of this School is learning how to effectively do that. And currently this class is failing.
So... I am going to move us forward soon, take the time to calm your character down some and lets move on in a more positive light.
Thank you,
M.