Yeah it's always nice to have a player stay in character. However at times that can be a bad thing but yet bad things happen in life so why not the game.
Bri you asked me the range from you to the Beholder and the Orc and I answered you on the Q/A it was over 250 yards. By Rayne attempting to shoot an arrow, even an energy arrow, that far Rayne would have known better then to try the shot and give away the element of surprise.
You could have asked me in PM or here in the Q/A if you fired would your arrow reach that far and I would have told you no. I have to be honest and say thank you for posting what you did as I had done all the rolls and had already half written the post.
Basically you all popped in using teleport right after Sirene's lightening bolt hurt the Beholder so bad 1-2 melee strikes would have killed it. After that the Orcs, though tougher then normal ones, think of the Orcs from Isengard instead of Morder. Would have been easy kills and you would have been dealing with healing the women.
Yet now I get to have funning killing you all.....
Ahh I mean..... wait.... ahh yeah I meant that

.