While Steelight has a good point in calculating the moves I would like to point out a few things myself.
1 2-4 bugbears (which with the exception of Steelight was what hogtied the rest of us) would be able to cumulatively do all required to hog tie us.
2 Actually Tus hate to bust your bubble yet again but with real game mechanics Ray of Frost doesn't even do what Tann described little own more.
3 Tann you lost my puppy! What happened to that ally that waiting on caused me to be hog tied?
4 while we're instructing we already know that Tann is one of the those Innmates that refuses to learn 3.5 in deference to 2.0 so he made up his own battle system. While a nasty surprise he's not the only one running a home made battle system. We just need to adjust. There will be different systems in use in every game we join. A good example is Season of the Witch where Tek tore us apart literally. (And by us I mean everyone except me

) Though with that as your defense Tann I for one would appreciate a better explanation of your system so that we could adjust or we can unemotionally help you learn 3.5's battle system. So we're not so easily toasted next time. Or we could have you translate the game to 2.0 since all that would change thus far is our character sheets, and we could continue on in 2nd.
5 while Tann did dismiss the class he gave us homework and perhaps he will teach based on our answers. Tann is a new teacher at the school we don't know his style give him some time before we start grilling him or do it in character.
I fully understand Steelight's frustration. In my pride I'd hoped I was a little better than a first round kill in any fight, but I wasn't fool enough to think the outcome wasn't predetermined. After all there was twelve of them and six of us. Bugbears in 3.5 have a CR of 2 I believe. While our own average level is 1. There was going to be defeat all over the place. The only ones who could stand up to a bugbear face to face is me and Steelight. So sure Steelight could have taken his first opponent but eventually he was going down too. It was a fun post to read even if it wasn't exactly routed in rules.
Except you? Wait a minute you little dwarf! I'm the only one who got out of that skirmish without any damage... okay so Thea's unconcious... that was my doing though
*wink*
-M