..... from what Mayor Ormond has told us and it being 4pm I propose the following for discussion.
Obviously Group 2 is closer to the Hermit and knowing who is in that party [without consulting what they are deciding In Game from this Q&A Thread that we are all reading!] it should be safe to assume that they will investigate the Hermit and be able to progress from there!
What I think we should do [and what the Paladin in particular would do at this point in time!] is go to Building #16 The Foaming Mug Inn and investigate the scene of battle for any clues while it is still daylight outside!]
We can leave the donkey and wagon there and we have enough rations to "Camp Out" in the ruins and see if we can draw any Evil out of hiding while we spend the night there!
This gives us the opportunity to look for clues and also puts us in the proximity of the others who returned after disappearing who are acting a bit odd at the nearby Buildings that Mayor Ormond has already revealed to us.
Also, we are making progress in the direction of the Temple that our friend Deathstalker is itching to investigate and at this point Gunther is inclined to follow Deathstalker wherever his blood lust wants to take him in the adventure!
So let's open it up for discussion and make a decision here and get the adventure progressing!
The only other question(s) I would ask Mayor Ormond is about the best place to settle for the night and more questions about The Foaming Mug Inn.
If we agree to go to The Foaming Mug Inn then we could inform Mayor Ormond as to our intent and ask him to send word to the local Constable and Militia that we are here to investigate the disappearances!
Perhaps Mayor Ormond would also be so kind as to send word to Group 2 to inform them as to where we are headed and to warn them about that Hermit ring leader [as Mayor Ormond suspects he might be!] who is hanging out at Building #27 and since the good Mayor Ormond would probably inform us that there is an Inn near there, then it may be safe to assume that our compatriots could be found there by a messenger from the mayor!
What does everyone else think about a plan of action?