Topic: Star Trek: The Scales of Eternity Subject: Ferrero Sees No Choice So He Makes A Choice
Stardate 2365.05.16 USS Peregrine, Ferrero's Quarters and Captain's Ready Room
Like everyone else on the Peregrine Ander Ferrero had been sitting around contemplating the situation with the asteroid ever since the situation had arisen. His original conviction had been to avoid breaking the prime directive – the directive was clear and the one sure way to steer clear of putting everyone in the crew in danger of violating it was to simply do nothing. Morally speaking, one was guilty of the sins one committed, not the things left uncommitted. So, do nothing, and they were in the clear.
But he could practically hear his abuela even as those thoughts came to him. “The only thing necessary for evil to triumph in the world was for good men to do nothing.” Ok, so that was really Edmund Burke, but it was exactly the kind of thing his grandmother would have said as she dragged him off to mass. Doing nothing, in the face of wrong, might be just as wrong. He hadn’t really been paying much attention to her at the time seeing as he’d been the one generally doing the wrong, but the words had apparently sunk in at some point.
But the problem was, there was no way to act in this situation and avoid breaking the prime directive. One either did nothing and watched 7 billion people die or one took an action which could ruin them. There was no middle ground. It was one or the other. He listened to the audio of the planet’s plea for help again. It had only come in recently, but it was his department, of course, that picked it up and so he had been one of the first to hear it. Why did the voice that begged for help somehow sound so much like his abuela?
He knew why.
Slowly, he got up and went to see the captain.
Ferrero pushed the comm button on the door frame of the ready room. “Commander Drake, Lieutenant Ferrero here, may I have some of your time?”
OOC: Assuming a positive response.
“Commander, I know that I have previously voiced skepticism about interfering in this situation. I know you have a lot to do – but I have a couple of thoughts I felt I needed to share. The first is that, I don’t think there is any way out of this situation without violating the Prime Directive. Literally nothing you do can avoid it.”
He took a deep breath and continued to explain. “Any action this ship takes to alter the course of that asteroid WILL impact those people. From the start the crew has been searching for a way to do this without being seen by those on the planet because if we are seen then we are effectively introducing advanced technology into their world. Yes, obviously, of course. But even if we do it unseen by those on the planet, we will be unavoidably changing their world in significant ways. Consider commander, what the people on the planet are saying right now. Science has told them that a doomsday asteroid is heading their way. People are people of whatever race Sir., and I can guarantee you that at this moment attendance is skyrocketing in whatever passes for a Church on that planet. If that asteroid suddenly explodes or diverts its course, people on that planet WILL give credit to something or someone. If they see us, it will be us. But if they don’t see us, then it will be to something else. Does taking an action to encourage the development of a giant theocracy sound like following the Prime Directive? Even if we could somehow shoot it with another asteroid to knock it off course by what would appear to those on the planet to be natural means, it would almost certainly have this effect. Either way, seen or unseen, a doomsday rock that changes its mind and the bell stops tolling? We will have changed that planet.” It was impossible as he gave this little speech to not hear his abuela giving credit for everything good in the world to God. Somehow God never got the blame when someone got shot, got sick or he was arrested. Or when giant asteroids doomed whole planets. Just the good things. But he knew what she would have done with a doomsday asteroid that didn’t doom anyone.
But that wasn’t the only option. “The other option is you could choose to do nothing, and technically that is not interfering, but as many have pointed out, the result is the loss of 7 billion people and an entire habitable world. And, Sir., while I would really prefer to avoid breaking the Prime Directive, I think that does so also. An entire planet will have its future changed . . . destroyed . . . obliterated. Changed. And while some would point out that WE didn’t do it, the equal truth is that ONLY WE could stop it. The result, whatever it is for that planet, will be a result of the choice made by this ship. Our choice, your choice, will change the future of that planet. It seems the Universe has not given you the option of following the Prime Directive. By the choice to act or the choice to not act, the Peregrine will determine a planet’s fate.”
OOC: Pausing a moment for reaction, if any.
Ferrero could hear his abuela in his head. He really hated that voice; sanctimonious and judgmental at the best of times as she dragged her grandchildren off to mass. But it was also a voice that had been echoing in his head throughout his life. He usually ignored it, but sometimes the little grandmother on his shoulder seemed to outweigh the little devil. He sighed.
“Commander, if we had a way to stick with the Prime Directive I might well continue to argue for that line. But I don’t think we do. And in the absence of a way to avoid breaking the Directive, there really only seems to be one choice. We need to stop it.”
OOC: Waiting for any response from the captain.
“Thank you for your time commander. I guess I will go see if there is anything I can do to assist with the scientific mission to the asteroid.”
As he turned to walk out of the room he looked back at the commander. “Commander, if the people on that planet have to give credit to either a scientific space-faring race or a deity, I’d rather science got the credit. Accidently being seen might not be a bad thing.”
Ferrero left the room and went back to his post on the bridge to see what communications from the planet had been picked up.
Posted on 2022-11-16 at 19:35:35.
|